Unveiling prevalence, persistence, and sources of fundamental chemical misconceptions among high school students using a four-tier diagnostic instrument
Authors: Ayalew Temesgen Eticha, Endale Teju, Kassu Biratu Bedassa, Daniel Deneke, Sisay Wondimu, Kasahun Ejigu, Teshome Bekele, Chala Takala, Wakshuma Yadesa Mergo
Journal: Chemistry Education Research and Practice
Publication year: 2026
DOI: 10.1039/d6rp00134c
Abstract
This study investigated the prevalence, nature, and sources of alternative conceptions (misconceptions) in chemistry among high school students, focusing on six fundamental topics: Chemical Bonding, Acid–Base Chemistry, Redox Reactions, Solutions of Matter, Electrochemistry, and Chemical Thermodynamics. Employing a descriptive research design, data were collected from a total of 740 students across multiple secondary and preparatory schools using four-tier multiple-choice diagnostic tests (4TMCT), open-ended questionnaires, and interview protocols. The collected data was analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively. Findings revealed varying rates of misconceptions across topics and grade levels. In chemical bonding, 13.5% of grade 10 and 21% of grade 12 students held misconceptions in the conceptual category of bond polarity, intermolecular forces, and the octet rule. Acid–base chemistry showed grade 10 and grade 12 students had misconceptions, with a pooled average of 12% across both grades. A total of 58.4% of Grade 12 students were found to be severely affected by misconceptions related to redox reactions. Solution chemistry revealed that an average of 43% of students held misconceptions. Electrochemistry misconceptions affected 44.44% of grade 12 students across different student samples, with particular difficulties in electrode processes, galvanic and electrolytic cells, and ion discharge predictions. Thermodynamics misconceptions affected students across concepts of enthalpy, heat, entropy, and system classifications, with an average medium-level misconception rate of 39%. Major sources of misconceptions across all topics included textbook figures and explanations, personal daily life experiences, teacher-related factors (instructional methods and English language proficiency), and knowledge carried forward from lower grades. The study concludes that chemistry misconceptions are persistent across grade levels and topics, with rates varying by concept complexity and grade level, highlighting the need for developmentally-appropriate, targeted instructional interventions to address these deeply-held alternative conceptions.